Is It Possible to Be Too Good?

January 29, 2020

Is it possible to be too good? Is it possible that thinking about morality could cause clinical levels of emotional and mental distress? On today’s show (hi, it’s been a while!), Christiane talks to two philosophers who explore a disorder known as Scrupulosity. People with Scrupulosity are obsessive about morality, checking and re-checking to make sure they haven’t done something wrong. Our guests, Walter Sinnott-Armstrong and Jesse Summers, explore the philosophical implications of these obsessions with moral behavior. Christiane also talks to Dr. Laura Crosskey, who treats patients with Scrupulosity.

Send questions or comments to

For the episode’s transcript, click here.

Don’t forget to check out the Prindle Institute’s newest podcast, Getting Ethics to Work!


Thanks to Evelyn Brosius for designing our logo. Our featured image was found here.

  1. Partly Sage” by Blue Dot Sessions, from (CC BY-NC 4.0)
  2. Cloudline” by Blue Dot Sessions, from (CC BY-NC 4.0)

To contact us, email